Insects That Mimic Stinging Wasps: A Look at Synanthedon acerni

In a previous post, I wrote about syrphid flies that mimic bees and wasps. But are there other insects with this mimicry superpower? The answer is yes. Other types of flies, beetles, and moths all have species that mimic stinging insects. The moth Superfamily Cossoidea (Carpenter and Clearwing Moths) is notable for the many species that mimic stinging wasps.

Synanthedon acerni (Family Sesiidae, Subfamily Sesiinae, Tribe Synanthedonini) is one such very wasp-like moth. Its wasp-like appearance allows it to be active during the day while it visits flowers, feeding on nectar.

Life history

The larvae of Synanthedon acerni are not quite as benign. Known as the maple callus borer moth, its larvae bore into the trunks of maple (Acer spp.) trees. Eggs are laid near wounds in the bark. Entry into the tree is through these wounds on the tree’s trunk. The larvae bore into the bark and then into the cambium, where they feed on the inner bark and sapwood. Feeding takes place during the summer within galleries. In the winter, they hibernate in the galleries and resume feeding in the spring.

At maturity, the larva constructs an oblong cocoon of wood fragments, frass, and silk within the gallery, close to the surface, covered by a thin escape window. When ready to emerge, the pupa cuts open the cocoon and the escape window. The fully formed Synanthedon acerni moth then exits the pupa, which is left partially stuck in the gallery.

The same tree may be used year after year, weakening it and eventually leading to its demise. A callus will form on the trunk after repeated infestations.

A neighborly moth

Genus overview

Haploa is a genus of moths in the superfamily Noctuoidea, family Erebidae, subfamily Arctiinae (Tiger and Lichen Moths). The genus comprises six species in North America north of Mexico and is not known from anywhere else. Four species are known from Minnesota: Haploa contigua, Haploa lecontei, Haploa reversa, and Haploa confusa.

So that’s the easy part. When I look over my photos of Haploa species, I am struck by the way Haploa lecontei, Haploa reversa, and Haploa confusa seem to grade into one another. Why? Maybe because I am misidentifying them. Or maybe because these are just photos of one species and its range of variation. Which species? I’m not sure anymore, but it might be Haploa confusa. The one I am sure of is Haploa contigua.

Haploa contigua

Haploa contigua is one of four species of Haploa with all white hindwings. The base color of the forewings is cream-colored to white. The costa and inner margins are bordered in dark brown. A diagonal dark brown line extends from the costa beyond the midpoint to the inner margin above the anal angle. Joining this is another line running from the outer margin. Haploa contigua lacks any lines or spurs in the antemedial portion of the forewing. All-white individuals are indistinguishable from other Haploa species with all-white forms.

Haploa contigua inhabits mesic woodlands to riparian woodlands. The larvae feed on the leaves of many species of woody and herbaceous plants.

The genus name “Haploa” is from the Greek word for “simplicity, singleness”, and the species epithet “contigua” is from the Latin word for “bordering” and so the neighbor moth.

Moths and Their Nighttime Floral Visits

*Xestia normanianus*, a dart moth, nectaring on lance-leaved aster (*Symphyotrichum lanceolatum*) at night.

What do moths do at night anyway? Some of them visit flowers for nectar.

Back in August, I was wandering about in the woods at night looking for foxfire fungi. At the head of the trail on my way out, I saw a sunflower plant with something on the flowers. It was a green tree cricket (Oecanthus) eating the stamens in the sunflower florets.

The next night, I went back but this time with my camera, hoping to find more tree crickets. I had my LED headlamp on like the previous night and used it to illuminate the flowers and foliage where I wanted to photograph. I also set the flash of my camera to “on”.

Although I could hear tree crickets in the bushes, I didn’t see any this time. What I did see were lots of moths on sunflowers and asters. Aiming the lamp’s beam at the flowers, I then pointed my camera at the moths and began taking photos. I wasn’t using a tripod, so many were blurry. Some were also overexposed by the bright LED light. But a few turned out.

*Feltia jaculifera* nectaring on a sawtooth sunflower (*Helianthus grosseratus*)

The moth species (Xestia normanianus, Feltia jaculifera, and Nephelodes minians) I found on flowers at night came as no surprise. These and other dart moth species are common visitors to my moth lights. But it was exciting to see them going about their normal activities in a natural setting. I never did find any foxfire this year.

**Moths weren’t the only visitors to flowers at night. I wonder if this crab spider was sleeping or waiting for a moth.**

I don’t remember planting this

At the end of my drive, I have a small planter partially embedded in the ground. In it, I plant sunflowers and heavenly blue morning glories. This year, I added red-leaved cannas. I also planted scarlet runner beans and thunbergia. Rabbits devoured those even with the fence. But the sunflowers, morning glories, and cannas survived.

To supplement the soil in the planter, I added some purchased compost. Usually, that’s a safe thing to do. Sometimes, though, I have gotten bonus plants like Ranunculus sceleratus (blistering buttercup) and Oxybasis glauca (oak-leaf pigweed). Not that I minded.

This year, Abutilon theophrasti (velvetleaf) came with the compost. Not that it bothers me. I have always found this tropical annual fascinating. Other people, like corn and soy farmers, would probably differ.

But I live far from big ag country. So this velvetleaf plant does not need to fear the sting of herbicides. Abutilon theophrasti, with its soft velvety, roundish leaves, their primary veins radiating from a central point, all connected by fine, parallel secondary veins, and branches tipped by tiny five-petaled orange flowers followed by enormous seed capsules, is welcome here if it behaves.